Company Claims Directory

During business hours, please contact us directly to report your claim. These numbers are provided as a convenience if you wish to report your claim directly to the insurance company when our office is closed.

Insurance Company (click to access their website) Phone Number
Acadia Insurance Company 800-773-4300
AmTrust 866-272-9267
Andover Insurance Company 800-225-0770
Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield 800-870-3122
Concord Group Insurance 800-888-6050
Co-Operative Insurance 877-210-8573
Delta Dental 800-832-5700
First Comp 888-500-3344
Foremost 800-527-3907
Hagerty Collector Car & Boat Insurance 800-922-4050 (Option #5)
Hartford 800-243-5860 Personal
800-327-3636 Business
Harvard Pilgrim Health Care 888-333-4742
Liberty Mutual Insurance 800-362-0000
MAPFRE 800-513-4813
MMG Insurance Company 888-869-8700
Merchants 800-258-3574 (Press 0)
National General Insurance Company 877-248-3455
Peerless Insurance Company 800-522-7152
Plymouth Rock 800-932-6288 (Option #2)
Progressive Insurance Company 800-776-4737 (Option #5)
Safeco 800-332-3226
Travelers 800-252-4633 (Option #1) Personal
800-238-6225 (Option #1) Business
Union Mutual Insurance Company 800-671-8552
U.S. Financial Life Insurance Company 800-959-3894 (Option #2)
Vermont Mutual Insurance Company 800-435-0397
Zurich Insurance Company 800-987-3373 (Option #1)